Liu Datian, an "imperial doctor", prescribed a prescription on the spot.
Red Star News reported on December 3 that a month ago, Liu Datian, a 70-year-old man who had been wandering outside for many years, suddenly became a "magic doctor". Every morning at 2: 00 or 3: 00, people queue up to see him, working 12 hours a day, and besides having three meals and sleeping, they are all prescribing prescriptions, and the consultation fee has also risen from 5 yuan to 100 yuan.
Among the "stories" circulating in the local area, Liu Datian once cured a child who was judged by the hospital to be "short of time" and also cured a hemiplegic patient to be "able to go to the fields to catch up". However, after investigation by reporters, it was found that the first story was unfounded and the second story was also false.
After verification by the local health law enforcement supervision brigade, Liu Datian has no medical qualification, and his medical place has been banned.
The tramp turned into a "magic doctor"
On November 29, the reporter went to Tianbao Village, Nanyue Town, Dachuan District. In a yard, there were 10 people warming themselves around the brazier in the courtyard dam. Under the eaves of blue bricks, there were a group of men and women around an old man with a white beard.
The old man, wearing a green coat, a washcloth on his left shoulder and a snow hat, is burying his head in writing prescriptions one by one, asking people who come to write prescriptions from time to time, "What other diseases are there?" "He is very slow in writing prescriptions, and it takes a big outline for 20 minutes." Ms. Jiang, in her 50 s, said.
At the scene, the reporter learned that the old man who prescribed the prescription is the legendary "imperial doctor", whose real name is Liu Datian, who is 74 years old.
Liu Datian writes prescriptions in his hometown, and about 30 people come to him to write prescriptions every day. My nephew Liu Sheng (a pseudonym) stands in line at the scene to keep order.
"30 a day, I have already got December 3, and I didn’t get the number on the 3 rd to get the number on the 4 th." Liu Sheng said. Because many people came to write prescriptions, Liu Sheng came to keep order and figure out how to queue up with numbers.
On the same day, the number of people who came to see Liu Datian increased one after another. At noon, Liu Datian ate a box lunch and began to "work" again until 7 o’clock in the evening. The reporter observed that Liu Datian is different from other doctors in seeing a doctor. He doesn’t care if the other person is a patient. No matter what the disease is, he can prescribe medicine as long as he can tell the symptoms.
The reporter found several prescriptions he prescribed and made a simple comparison. The prescriptions were all one or two (traditional old-fashioned prescription measurement units), and a prescription contained at least 10 kinds of Chinese medicines and at most 25 kinds of Chinese medicines, and some Chinese medicines were repeated in the prescriptions.
Wu Zejun, a villager in Liu Datian’s village group, said that Liu Datian used to be a "doctor" and it is more accurate to define him as a "quack doctor". Liu Datian had been working as a "barefoot doctor" in Pingtan Township and Anji Township in Dachuan District. His family was not bad. When he was young, his family changed suddenly, and his wife left, leaving only him and his younger brother to live. Later, Liu Datian wandered outside for about 50 years. "Because my brother still beats him from time to time, Liu Datian wanders outside and rarely goes home." Wu Zejun said.
Guo Tingyuan, the old secretary of the village, said that Liu Datian had been wandering around Nanyue Town and became a famous tramp in Nanyue Town, looking for leftovers to take home for his younger brother.
Liu Datian usually sleeps in a brick factory when he doesn’t go home. If he really can’t find food, he will also ask others for "one or two yuan" and don’t want more money.
As for Liu Datian’s prescription, everyone in Nanyue Town knows that it took about a month to return to his hometown Tianbao Village in the last week.
On November 30th, a woman who lives in Nanyue Town came to write prescriptions. She told reporters that when Liu Datian, a "magic doctor", wrote prescriptions in the street, about 100 people lined up to ask him to write prescriptions every day, some at two or three o’clock in the morning. Liu Datian had almost no rest except for three meals a day and sleeping. "All of them were writing prescriptions (prescriptions)".
Resident Deng Shengbai introduced that Liu Datian went to sleep under the eaves of his home half a month ago. At that time, there were about 200 people who saw him every day, and their doors were packed. Some people came from Chengdu, Chongqing and Guang ‘an, and others came from Dazhou City and nearby towns and villages.
According to the residents around, Liu Datian practiced medicine in Deng Shengbai’s place for about a week, and people were full every day. Because he practiced medicine without a license, Nanyue Town Government and Dachuan District Health Law Enforcement Supervision Brigade banned his place of practice, and then Liu Datian returned to his hometown.
The consultation fee rose from 5 yuan to 100 yuan.
At 11 o’clock on the evening of the 29th, the reporter came to Liu Datian’s hometown. Three women were warming themselves in Liu Datian’s house, waiting for Liu Datian to get up and prescribe medicine.
"The two of us have been here several times, but we haven’t got a prescription. (29th) We didn’t have breakfast in the morning, lunch and dinner, just to make a prescription for a number." Zheng Fen (a pseudonym), a woman from Nanyue Town, said.
At 1 o’clock in the morning on the 30th, four women from Dazhou City rented a car to queue up. Two hours later, several people came to ask Liu Datian for a prescription. Liu Datian didn’t get up until after 5 o’clock in the morning.
After Liu Datian sat down, he had to pay for the prescription first. Four women from Dazhou gave it to 300 yuan. Liu Datian said, "400 yuan delayed my drowsiness, or I wouldn’t open it." Four women borrowed 100 yuan from an acquaintance at the scene, and Liu Datian wrote four lists, and then four women left by bus.
Zheng Fen told reporters that November 29th was a prescription for 50 yuan, but it rose to 100 yuan on November 30th. The reason for this price increase is uncertain. "200 yuan, 300 yuan and 20 yuan, 10 yuan behind us, which were given by rich people, can’t get it, and now the general price is 100 yuan."
Deng Shengbai told reporters that when Liu Datian saw a doctor and prescribed a prescription at his doorstep, 5 yuan gave a prescription at that time, and some gave it to 10 yuan. This charge is not fixed. If the rich give it to 100 yuan and 200 yuan, he will open it first, while others will wait in line if they give less money.
Liu Sheng, Liu Datian’s nephew, said: "There are still people from 500 yuan and 1000 yuan. He (Liu Datian) wants to accept it, and he will prescribe it first."
On December 3rd, the reporter went to Liu Datian’s home again, and 100 yuan wrote a prescription. First, he gave money, then registered, and finally he saw a doctor and wrote a prescription.
Liu Datian’s prescription fee record.
Reporter’s investigation: Both "stories" are rumors.
Why do so many people find a tramp "magic doctor" to prescribe medicine? A woman who saw a doctor at the scene said, "I heard that he cured a child who could not be cured in a big hospital." There is also a paralyzed patient who has been cured by him for more than 10 years. "
As a tramp, Liu Datian suddenly turned into a "imperial doctor", and these two stories are circulating in the streets of Nanyue Town and in the mouths of villagers:
One story is that there is a child in a town not far from Nanyue Town. After being treated in a big hospital in Chengdu, the conclusion is that the child’s time is running out. My family suddenly had a dream one night, dreaming that someone said that finding a vagrant and beggar to prescribe a prescription could cure the disease. After inquiring, I finally found Liu Datian and prescribed a prescription, and the child recovered after eating it. Another story is that a paralyzed patient took the medicine prescribed by Liu Datian and was able to go to the streets to catch the show.
Are the two seemingly absurd stories true?
The reporter inquired in many ways and did not find the specific home address and contact information of the child in the first story. Liu Sheng, Liu Datian’s nephew, also said that he didn’t know about it himself. He asked Liu Datian, but he didn’t know, and the other party didn’t leave any contact information.
Regarding the paralyzed patient who went to the streets after taking medicine, the reporter contacted Wu Moumou, the family member of this person. In Wu’s home, he took out his and his wife’s prescriptions.
Wu Moumou said that he got up early in the morning and went to the street to find Liu Datian to prescribe a prescription, and took the medicine home to his wife. "After you boil it out, drink a small bowl three times a day." Wu Moumou said. After taking the medicine, my wife seems to be in better spirits.
Wu Moumou introduced that his wife, Yang, did take a trip to the street. She left by herself. "On that day, she didn’t take medicine for cerebral thrombosis. After returning home, she was weak and bedridden again and was sent to the hospital for treatment."
Is it Liu Datian’s medicine that makes his wife walk in the fields again? Wu Moumou said that this is not the truth. "She can usually walk at home, but slowly." Wu Moumou said.
Patient: I don’t believe that he is an imperial doctor, but I have a try attitude.
The reporter found that the people who came to seek Liu Datian’s medical treatment were almost all people in their 50 s and 60 s.
Shao Yinyin (a pseudonym) from Dazhou City introduced that he didn’t believe that he was a "magic doctor". He just heard a friend say that Liu Datian was quite hot recently, and the medicine he prescribed was effective. He specially drove from Dazhou overnight to Nanyue Town to find him and prescribed a medicine, "Try it for a mentally ill son".
On December 3, Shao Yinyin called the reporter and said that she had seen a doctor. Liu Datian prescribed a medicine for treating stomach problems for her son. "The medicine was caught, so I dare not give it to my son."
On the same day, a couple who were still waiting for Liu Datian’s prescription introduced that his wife was suffering from tuberculosis and had not recovered for a long time. They came to ask Liu Datian for a prescription from Dazhou. The couple said that they also heard from others that the prescription was effective after eating. "Let’s try it on purpose, in case it works." As for the statement that Liu Datian is a "magic doctor", they said that doctors can’t cure all diseases.
Local health law enforcement brigade: it has no medical qualification and its medical place has been banned.
The reporter learned from the Dachuan District Health Law Enforcement Supervision Brigade that after Liu Datian practiced medicine, after investigation, they found that he was a vagrant and a five-guarantee household, and he practiced medicine without a license.
"When we went to law enforcement, we asked him something, but he didn’t say it." Dai Zhonghua, the captain of the Dachuan District Health Law Enforcement Supervision Brigade, said.
At the scene, law enforcement officers publicized on the spot that it was illegal to practice medicine without a license, and posted notices in the place where he practiced medicine, banning Liu Datian’s medical place.
On behalf of Zhonghua, strictly speaking, compulsory measures should be taken against him, but considering that the old man is over 70 years old and has been wandering for a long time, he is in poor health and has not taken compulsory measures. He can only be warned not to practice medicine.
According to the reporter, after the handling by the law enforcement brigade, Liu Datian returned to his village and continued to prescribe drugs. On December 3rd, Dachuan District Health Law Enforcement Supervision Brigade visited Liu Datian’s hometown again.
Deng Zezhang, secretary of the Party Committee of Nanyue Town, introduced that after the occurrence of Liu Datian’s unlicensed medical practice, Nanyue Town organized a meeting of members of the Party Committee in view of Liu Datian’s unlicensed medical practice, and took measures to post an announcement in the town and hometown to inform everyone that Liu Datian was practicing medicine without a license, and used a loudspeaker to walk around the street to publicize and greet the pharmacies on the street. Anyone holding Liu Datian’s list was not allowed to sell drugs.
The reporter saw that the announcement posted by the People’s Government of Nanyue Town showed: "Liu Datian, a villager in Group 4 of Tianbao Village, Nanyue Town, male, aged 74, is a poor person and has been suspected of mental disorder for about 50 years. Liu Datian is now prescribing for others in Pailu Village. It has been found that Liu Datian has no doctor qualification certificate and is not qualified to practice medicine. The District Health Law Enforcement Brigade has been involved in the investigation and found that Liu Datian is suspected of illegally practicing medicine. "
The announcement also mentioned that the prescription prescribed by Liu Datian has great security risks, and no pharmacy, clinic, hospital or clinic may provide drugs for prescriptions prescribed by illegal medical practitioners.
Chinese medicine expert: This is slandering Chinese medicine. There is no "magic doctor" who can cure all diseases.
The reporter contacted Wang Gang, the president and chief physician of Dazhou Hospital of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine. After reviewing the prescriptions of Wu Moumou and Yang Moumou, he introduced that the prescription prescribed by Liu Datian was unreasonable, the pharmacology was unknown, the rules were confusing, the drugs were repeated (fragrant, woody), and the dosage was wrong (the Pharmacopoeia had long required prescriptions to be used without money), and it was impossible to see what diseases could be cured by physical strength.
Wang Gang introduced that Chinese medicine pays attention to "looking, smelling, asking and cutting", and collects the condition through these ways, and diagnoses the condition by integrating various situations. "It is irresponsible for patients to prescribe drugs only when they ask about their illness, and if the information about their illness is not collected, they should not be allowed to ruin the cause of Chinese medicine." Wang Gang said.
Diao Benshu, the chief physician of the Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine of the Seventh People’s Hospital of Chengdu and a famous Chinese medicine practitioner in Sichuan, said, "The so-called imperial doctors are all deceptive." Traditional Chinese medicine pays attention to "looking, smelling, asking and feeling", depending on the patient’s look and form, listening to the voice expression, feeling the pulse, watching the thickness of muscles and loose hair, listening to the patient’s voice, etc., and drawing a comprehensive conclusion through the information obtained in these four ways. Prescribing a prescription without looking at the patient himself is too simple. Diao Benshu said: "This practice is mystifying and slandering Chinese medicine."
According to Diao Benshu, in most cases, it is impossible to cure all diseases with one medicine of "imperial doctor", but it can alleviate many symptoms. He said: "There are many factors affecting the curative effect of traditional Chinese medicine. It is wrong to blow traditional Chinese medicine too wonderfully and cure everything. Don’t trust the so-called’ magic doctor’."
(The original title is "The 74-year-old tramp becomes a" magic doctor ",and the consultation fee has risen from 5 yuan to 100. The health law enforcement department has banned it")
